Peeling Back The Layers
Yesterday Deon Daugherty with the Houston Business Journal called and asked if I would comment on a recent article in The Onion about the increase in job opportunities for recent PR grads in the fracking industry.
For the uninitiated, The Onion, which labels itself as a satirical news outlet, in some parts of society is viewed as a reliable news source, but in reality it is about a step below The National Enquirer.
Considering someone from the Fifth Ring team is on the phone with a reporter from the HBJ (seemingly) on a daily basis securing or staffing an interview, I figured it was the least I could do. Click here to read Deon’s blog post.
Of course, it didn’t take long to determine The Onion article was less than thorough and ultimately it got me thinking about a couple of things…
Specifically, where did the idea come from that companies hire PR people to shield them from controversy or help them come up with ways to keep secrets secret? This couldn’t be further from the truth. Most are wholly interested in helping their clients do the right things and generate compelling stories that advance the brand in some way.
Do we get called in to help (re)position the client in the best possible light when times are tough or when there has been a corporate misstep? Of course we do. But rarely does that conversation happen without a PR pro seeking clarity and advocating for stakeholder visibility. Typically this comes with some sort of mea culpa and a plan to correct the issue.
Are there illegitimate PR practitioners who violate all manner of professional ethics and morals? Of course there are, but you have that in every profession.
Ben Franklin said “three can keep a secret if two are dead.” Given the nature of the digital world as we know it today, it is inevitable that secrets do not stay secret and wrongdoing will eventually be found out. So, companies—no matter the industry—would be well advised to heed the counsel of public relations people who are guided by a code of ethics that was written with the wellbeing of the general public in mind.
More often than not, the principles of PR are put to use to ensure a company or spokesperson doesn’t inadvertently say the wrong thing and thus create an issue when in fact there isn’t one.
The next thing that struck me was how can The Onion get away with referencing a “labor market report” without any mention of who authored the report or even the title? The article has gone on to be quoted or referenced on dozens of online sites with none questioning the premise of the report, article or the source.
One reporter, Susan Phillips of State Impact Pennsylvania, which contributes to WHYY and WITF, called it a joke.
If we do operate under the premise that the article is a bit of a ruse, then the following quote from The Onion’s story might be a great example of a person being quoted who should have utilized PR assistance.
Regarding recent PR grads, Bart Hobijn observed:
"These days, media-savvy professionals who know how to publicize questionable scientific data in order to downplay the environmental dangers of forcing toxic fluids into the ground can pretty much write their own ticket."
I don’t know how many “recent PR grads” you know, but I have yet to meet one who was a savvy enough to do what Mr. Hobijn suggests. I suppose the same could be said of economists and researchers who used questionable methods and data to assure the public that investing in banks who participated in credit-default swaps was in fact a sound, strategic investment.
That being said, the quote seems misinformed given the unsourced nature of the survey. My guess is he said it as a private citizen and not in an official capacity, but The Onion portrays him as the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco’s spokesperson offering comment on behalf of the federal government.
Clearly the PR industry could stand to do a bit of good PR on its own behalf, but I would be willing to bet Mr. Hobijn is wishing he had a PR person helping him potentially dig out of a hole right now. If he does indeed need some assistance, I know some savvy folks right there in San Francisco who would be willing to help out.

